Not long ago, someone with Trump's enlightened vision, would have called Italy a shithole country. In the same category would be other countries, for instance, Ireland, Scotland and all Eastern European countries (most of all those that "sent" to America their Jews).
Canada? A shithole too: that's why we tried to invade it in the war of 1812.
Spain and its colonies (Philippines etc.)? You got it: all shitholes.
If we went back far enough, even Germany would qualify (Benjamin Franklin wanted to stop immigration of Germans. Too many! And they want to speak German! Can you believe the nerve?)
So, to summarize: most of us or our predecessors came here from a shithole country.
And here is a column by someone who freely admits he came from another obscure shithole, and now lives in a country (ours) full of people from shithole countries.
As tourist
destinations go, the Republic of Moldova — tucked between Ukraine and Romania —
probably isn’t on anyone’s bucket list. It’s the poorest country in Europe,
with per capita G.D.P. barely exceeding Sudan’s. Sex trafficking and organized
crime are rampant. My memories of the place, from a visit 17 years ago, include
roads that vanished into deep snow, Transnistrian border guards in Soviet
uniforms, and an impoverished Holocaust survivor’s tale of a bleak life under
Romanian, German and Soviet tyrants.
Let’s not mince
words: Moldova is a hole. Modify with any four letters you wish.
I mention
Moldova because it’s where my paternal grandfather was born in 1901. An
anti-Semitic rampage in his hometown, Kishinev, soon forced his family to leave
for New York, where my great-grandfather labored as a carpenter in the Brooklyn
Navy Yard for eight dollars a week. Low skills, low wages, minimal English, lots
of children and probably not the best hygiene — that’s half of my pedigree. The
other half consisted of refugees.
I’m not alone.
America is a nation of holers. It is an improbable yet wildly successful
experiment in the transformation — by means of hope, opportunity and ambition —
of holers into doers, makers, thinkers and givers. Are you of Irish descent?
Italian? Polish? Scottish? Chinese? Chances are, your ancestors did not get on
a boat because life in the old country was placid and prosperous and grandpa
owned a bank. With few exceptions, Americans are the dregs of the wine, the
chaff of the wheat. If you don’t know this by now, it makes you the wax in the
ear.
Donald Trump is
the wax in the ear.
Some of the
fury — and most of the apologetics — surrounding the president’s alleged remark
about “all these people from shithole countries” concerns the nature of the
countries themselves. Liberals can be squeamish about calling poor countries
bad names, while conservatives such as Mark Steyn chortle that “nobody
voluntarily moves to Haiti.” Which, let’s be real, is basically right.
Yet that’s
beside the point. We are not talking about Haiti, El Salvador, Nigeria or any
other country on the president’s insult list. What counts are the people from
these countries, both those who are already in the United States as well as
those who wish to come. Why should the president think they are any less fit to
become Americans than the Norwegians he seems to fancy?
The obvious
answer is racism, the same “textbook” case that Paul Ryan spoke of in June 2016
after Trump called a federal judge’s fitness into question on account of his
ethnic heritage.
What about the
argument that people from poor countries bring their national baggage with them
— the dysfunctions and prejudices that help account for their troubles back
home?
But immigrants
are more likely to be fleeing those dysfunctions and prejudices than they are
to be bringing them — just ask Dorsa Derakhshani, the international chess
master from Iran who came to the United States last year because, as she wrote
in an op-ed for The Times, the mullahs “cared more about the scarf covering my
hair than the brain under it.” Vietnamese boat people did not bring fratricidal
hatreds with them to America. Soviet refuseniks did not bring a Soviet work
ethic.
This should go
without saying, except that the age of Trump is also the age in which
restatements of the obvious have become necessary for civilization. Also
obvious is that immigrants don’t steal jobs. They fill jobs Americans won’t do
or create those that haven’t been invented. They don’t bring crime to cities.
They drive out crime by starting businesses and families in shrinking cities or
underserved neighborhoods. They don’t undermine American culture. They
feed, enrich and reinvent it, not least through their educational ambitions for
themselves and their children.
This is true of most immigrants, but perhaps more so of the so-called “holers.” As Michelle Mittelstadt of the Migration Policy Institute notes, sub-Saharan Africans have “among the highest college-completion rates of any immigrant group.” As for Haitians, MPI found they had a higher labor participation rate than the overall work force, and had median household incomes of $47,200 — lower than the overall U.S. median, but robust by any developed nation standard.
How can this be? It shouldn’t be a mystery. Immigrants self-select. They have a broader perspective. They know their luck. They want it more. The miraculous in America is mostly invisible to those who’ve known nothing else. To really see it clearly, you must first rise up from a hole.
Donald Trump
has not, to say the least, risen from a hole. But he is sinking into one. It
may be that it won’t damage him politically — Republican Party leaders,
increasingly unshameable, will mumble mild disapproval until the news cycle
turns — but it
does damage the country. We have a president even more ignorant of America than
he is of the rest of the world.
Maybe there
really is something wrong with the president’s head. Modify with any four
letters you wish.
This is true of most immigrants, but perhaps more so of the so-called “holers.” As Michelle Mittelstadt of the Migration Policy Institute notes, sub-Saharan Africans have “among the highest college-completion rates of any immigrant group.” As for Haitians, MPI found they had a higher labor participation rate than the overall work force, and had median household incomes of $47,200 — lower than the overall U.S. median, but robust by any developed nation standard.
How can this be? It shouldn’t be a mystery. Immigrants self-select. They have a broader perspective. They know their luck. They want it more. The miraculous in America is mostly invisible to those who’ve known nothing else. To really see it clearly, you must first rise up from a hole.
The ease with which many Americans display cognitive dissonance of their own history and heritage is always disturbing. Fundamentally, no one except the various confederacies, nations, and tribes of Native Americans can 'claim' ancestral ownership with this portion of North America. If one attempts to define true Americans only as those who have been here all this time, this would include a very small number of English, Scotch-Irish, and BLACK individuals. It is simply hypocritical for the many conservative voters to spout anti-immigration rhetoric, when they may only be a few generations shy of immigration or refugee status. In particular, I am disturbed by (such xenophobic) Irish- and Italian-Americans whose ancestors came to the United States within the last 150 years. These immigrants faced discrimination in jobs, language, and culture within their earliest days. Unfortunately, the assimilation of these groups into 'white American' culture has allowed them to reorient against the very kind of people (immigrants) that were once their only allies in this country. In regard to immigration policy, American selfishness knows no bounds.
ReplyDelete